The Ideology of Reading

The Reading Instruction Show by Dr. Andy Johnson

Episode notes

Despite having the word “science” in their title, the proposals put forth by the SoR are not grounded in science at all, but in pseudo-science, I-think-isms, and anecdotal evidence. In fact, they are promoting an ideology.

Real science. Real science puts forth conclusions and recommendations based on a wide body of research. Real science uses systematic methods to collect and analyze data. Real science draws conclusions only from data collected. And real science uses blind peer review for an objective system of checks and balances.

Ideology. An ideology is a system of ideas and beliefs. An ideology puts forth a dogma based on a very narrow range of data that must be adhered to. What the SOR promotes is based far more on a reading belief system than reading science. Hence, the SOR would be mo ... 

 ...  Read more
Keywords
reading instructionandy johnsonpeer reviewed researchpeer reviewed reading researchscientifically based researchscientifically based reading researcheducational researchscience of readingsorbalanced literacyreading science